Nonprofit organizations depend on the expertise and dedication of their board members to steer strategy, provide oversight, and uphold governance. A key topic that often arises in this context is board member compensation—whether and how nonprofit board members should be compensated for their service.
While board membership is traditionally seen as a voluntary role, understanding the complexities of board member compensation is crucial for ensuring legal compliance, maintaining transparency, and fostering organizational sustainability.
This guide delves into the legal frameworks, advantages, and challenges of compensating nonprofit board members, offering practical insights to help organizations make informed decisions.
Nonprofit Resources
The Charity Charge resource hub is dedicated to providing tips, tools, and information to help your nonprofit create and grow a modern organization. Learn more
What is Nonprofit Board Member Compensation?
Nonprofit board member compensation refers to financial or in-kind benefits provided to individuals serving on the board of directors. These benefits might include:
- Stipends or salaries
- Reimbursement for travel or related expenses
- Honorariums for specific services
- Per diem allowances
While compensating board members is more common in for-profit organizations, nonprofits may also choose to compensate board members under specific circumstances.
Related post: How to Start a Nonprofit Board: A Step-by-Step Guide
Nonprofit Board Member Compensation Ranges
Small Nonprofits ($0 – $5,000)
Small nonprofits, often operating on tight budgets, rely heavily on volunteer board members. In these organizations, compensation is typically non-monetary, such as public recognition or access to professional development opportunities.
When financial compensation is offered, it usually comes in the form of small stipends or reimbursement for direct expenses like travel, meals, or accommodation for attending board meetings. This approach ensures inclusivity by removing financial barriers for board members who might otherwise struggle to participate.
Medium Nonprofits ($5,000 – $15,000)
Medium-sized nonprofits often balance the need to attract skilled professionals with budget constraints. These organizations may offer modest stipends or honorariums to recognize the time and expertise board members contribute.
Compensation at this level helps to recruit individuals with specific skills, such as financial management or legal expertise, who might not be able to serve on a completely volunteer basis. Additionally, expense reimbursements and allowances for events, training, or retreats are commonly included in this range.
Large Nonprofits ($15,000 – $50,000)
Large nonprofits often compete with corporate boards for experienced and talented individuals. As a result, compensation at this level becomes more structured and competitive. Board members in these organizations may receive regular stipends, travel allowances, or additional benefits such as networking opportunities and access to exclusive events. Organizations in this category often justify higher compensation by emphasizing the significant governance responsibilities and time commitments expected from their board members.
Major Foundations ($50,000 – $100,000+)
Major foundations with substantial budgets often provide significant compensation packages to attract high-profile and experienced professionals. Board members in these organizations are typically responsible for overseeing large-scale operations and managing significant endowments or grant-making activities.
Compensation may include stipends, per diem payments, and even performance-based bonuses, though these must be carefully structured to avoid conflicts of interest or public scrutiny. Transparency and compliance with nonprofit laws are critical at this level to maintain the organization’s credibility.
International NGOs ($25,000 – $75,000)
International NGOs, which operate on a global scale, frequently compensate their board members at rates consistent with international governance standards. Compensation often reflects the complexity of the organization’s work, which may involve overseeing multiple programs across various countries and managing diverse stakeholder relationships.
In addition to financial compensation, board members often receive reimbursements for travel to international meetings or site visits. Perks such as accommodations, health insurance, or professional development opportunities are also common in this range.
Legal Framework for Nonprofit Board Member Compensation
1. IRS Regulations on Compensation
The IRS permits nonprofit organizations to compensate board members, provided the amounts are “reasonable” and align with the organization’s bylaws and mission. However, excessive compensation may trigger penalties under IRS intermediate sanctions rules.
2. State Laws and Nonprofit Standards
State laws vary regarding nonprofit board member compensation. Some states discourage or limit compensation to preserve the nonprofit’s tax-exempt status. Nonprofits should consult state-specific statutes before making compensation decisions.
3. Conflict of Interest Policies
When compensating board members, nonprofits must adopt robust conflict of interest policies to avoid perceived or actual self-dealing. Transparent decision-making ensures accountability and public trust.
Pros of Nonprofit Board Member Compensation
- Attracting Skilled Talent
Compensation can help nonprofits attract experienced professionals who might otherwise prioritize paid opportunities. - Recognizing Commitment
Compensating board members acknowledges the significant time and effort they dedicate to the organization’s success. - Enhancing Accountability
Paid board members may feel a greater sense of responsibility and accountability in fulfilling their duties.
Cons of Nonprofit Board Member Compensation
- Potential for Public Criticism
Compensation may raise eyebrows among stakeholders, especially in organizations reliant on donor funding. - Legal and Tax Implications
Improperly managed compensation can lead to penalties or jeopardize the nonprofit’s tax-exempt status. - Financial Constraints
For smaller nonprofits, compensating board members may strain already limited resources.
Best Practices for Nonprofit Board Member Compensation
1. Conduct Market Research
Use benchmarking studies to determine reasonable compensation levels for board members in similar organizations.
2. Establish Clear Policies
Draft compensation policies that outline eligibility, approval processes, and payment methods. Ensure these policies are reviewed and approved by non-compensated board members or an independent committee.
3. Maintain Transparency
Disclose compensation practices in annual reports and Form 990 filings to build donor trust.
4. Consult Legal and Financial Experts
Engage nonprofit attorneys or CPAs to ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations.
FAQs
What are the legal requirements for compensating nonprofit board members?
Nonprofit board member compensation must adhere to IRS regulations, state laws, and the organization’s bylaws. Compensation should be reasonable and well-documented.
Is nonprofit board member compensation taxable?
Yes, compensation received by board members is generally taxable income and must be reported on tax returns.
Can all nonprofits compensate their board members?
Most nonprofits can compensate board members, but some states or organizational bylaws may impose restrictions.
What is considered “reasonable” compensation?
Reasonable compensation aligns with industry benchmarks and reflects the scope of responsibilities undertaken by the board member.
How should nonprofits disclose board member compensation?
Compensation details should be included in Form 990 filings, annual reports, and financial disclosures to ensure transparency.
What alternatives exist to compensating board members?
Nonprofits may offer non-monetary recognition, reimburse expenses, or provide training opportunities to show appreciation for board members’ service.
